The first time I crossed the line separating the men and women’s prayer sections I was elated and terrified of being caught. It was like walking down into a dark basement to pick up a jar of pickles from cold storage. Slow, tentative steps gauge just how safe it is in the dark — but the second you turn your back, you can feel unseen eyes pricking your neck and long, icy fingers chasing you, ready to grab you and pull you into the depths if you falter for just a moment while racing back up the stairs. Escaping that which lurks in the deep, you pant heavily, pickles in hand, adrenaline still pumping, thankful for having escaped.
I actually think I tiptoed in.
It was an experience of opposites: I felt exposed, yet giddy as a sweet tooth in a candy store — I wanted to linger, but my mind rushed me just in case someone saw my trespass. Being so close to the minbar was like I had entered a sacred, forbidden space. Forbidden for me.
God was closer here, than in my regular spot way in the back of the room. It was cleaner, brighter and for once I could really admire the beautiful pieces of Islamic art up close. Even the books were newer and the full carpet was softer and more lush than our thin, mismatched rugs — I wiggled my toes. Is that a crate of water bottles? Ooh, incense! So that’s what the whiteboard says. Hey, what are they doing with boxes of chocolate and cookies?
I heard a noise behind me and like a frightened rabbit, flew back to the woman’s section with my heart racing. That was my first real experience of mosque inequities. I was elated as if I had gotten away with something naughty, and yet, saddened by the obvious differences between the male and female spaces. It was as if the mosque was telling me, “men are welcome here, you, not so much.” After that, I couldn’t help but acknowledge just how second class I felt at the mosque.
The second time was at the Blue Mosque in Istanbul. When we went, part of the men’s section was cordoned off for tourists, presumably non-Muslim tourists — allowing space for people to pray undisturbed and for people to get just a little closer to the ornate wooden carvings, historical calligraphies, and gold embossed decor (things may be different now, anyone care to elaborate?). I went to pray at the back in women’s section and watched aghast, as men moved freely throughout the entire mosque while tour guides kept their groups in hushed pockets behind a velvet rope. I sat in my section, bored and yearning to get closer to the gorgeous architecture. The Hubby was taking a detail shot of the minbar when I said, “oh forget this,” and walked right into the men’s section to join him.
Both times nothing bad happened. No lighting bolts. No irate imam pushing me back into my corner. And yet it’s a given in many mosques, that men and women’s spaces are largely impenetrable (although, I’ve experienced more men wandering, lingering or arguing their way into the sister’s section more often than women moving into the men’s section. Often they’re chased out with a good chappal smack). It’s unfortunately that in some mosques the keys to Islamic education, direct access to (male) scholars, history, literature, and chocolate are one sided.
When entering the prayer space, it’s easy to fall into assumed roles and positions used during the prayer — be it women praying side-by-side with men, in a separate room, in the rows directly behind men, cordoned off by a barrier, or at the far end of a hall. It’s like choosing “your seat” in the first class of the semester. But there is nothing barring women from entering “male space” when prayer is not in session. We have every right to be granted access to these spaces.
What I’d like to know, from both my male and female readers, is have you ever “crossed the line” and how did it make you feel?

February 1, 2011 at 1:39 am
Assalamu alaykum
Good for you! I haven’t the huevos to go into the men’s section, although I am dying to see it. Oh, Ive been in some pretty despicable women’s prayer spaces, and now don’t go at all out of frustration.
I bit my nails through this post girl!
I can’t wait for my tiny girl to stand beside Baba for iqamah like my son does. Sadly I will be watching from a balcony. And when she’s old enough to ask me about it, I don’t know what I will do.
Does your spouse hold similar views as you? My husband can be old school at times, and there are other times when he completely surprises me.
I personally tink we all can be in the same space (gasp, breathing the same air (gasp0. Until this becomes widespread, I think women are not receiving the full benefits of attending the mosque.
That baby of yours is awfully cute teehee! I saw her cheeks in a previous post! And that little nose! Sweet!
Did you return to work yet?
February 1, 2011 at 10:26 pm
wa ‘alaikum salaam!
Altmuslima has a great article called, Mommy, Why are women in the back?”. It’s an interesting read.
I’m not quite sure what I’m going to say to Eryn either. Something we should all hash out in another post perhaps.
My Hubby sounds similar to yours. For the most part we’re on the same page — and actually more so since I’ve started this blog (I’m not sure if it’s because he’s reading and discussing things with me, or if it’s because I’ve changed his mind on a couple of things!) I was day dreaming having a son the other day, and decided that I would be pretty disappointed if a younger son lead prayer before Eryn, or if the Hubby expected myself and Eryn to pray behind himself and the boy — instead of all praying together as a family.
(Sweetheart, you reading this?
)
I start work on Monday. *shudder* I feel a little sick just thinking about it.
February 2, 2011 at 1:44 am
Thanks for the link
I hope to soften my spouse just a wee bit. Its a process like anything else. I dont want to change who he is, but I would like for him to really see being muslim though my eyes.
Good luck at work. I had to bring my son’s receiving blanket with me because it smelled like him. I also had loads of pics and vids on my phone. It kept me going.
February 1, 2011 at 1:08 pm
When I lived in China, many of the mosques had no women’s spaces at all, so I just sat at the back of the men’s space. I would often arrive before the last of the stragglers, so men would have to pray behind me, on the staircase. No lightning bolts there, either.
February 1, 2011 at 10:36 pm
That’s brilliant — tell me more! Did other women attend as well? Or were you the only trailblazer? I suppose when it comes to necessity, “expected decorum” is thrown out the window.
Once at an Islamic bookstore, I was praying in their basement musallah (a tiny alcove underneath the stairs) — it had just enough room for 2 or 3 people. After the first rakat a man came up beside me and started praying, but he was really close and following my motions, as if I were leading prayer. It was pretty dark, and maybe he thought I was a man — but I was wearing an abaya… so..?
February 10, 2011 at 6:27 pm
Sorry for the delay in responding – was out for a bit. So, the mosque I attended was a Hui mosque. The Hui are a Muslim minority that are seen as “Chinese” – they look Chinese, speak Chinese. In other parts of the country (like Anhui province) there are womens’ mosques lead by female imams. The woman started them because they wanted their own space.
Xinjiang, though, is very different, and that’s where I lived. I’m pretty sure that there might have been men that were shocked to see me there (I was the only woman present, as women in that area are generally encouraged to stay home), but no one stared or put up a fuss or even said anything to me at all. I tried to be inconspicuous, but it was tough. I’m not going to say that no women EVER attended, because they did have a separate wudu room for ladies.
Contrast this to the Uighur mosque that I went to visit, where I was not only NOT allowed inside, but was told that, if I really needed to pray (this was as the adhan was sounding), I could pray on the muddy mat where men scraped the muck off of their boots as they came in the front door.
February 1, 2011 at 1:20 pm
A couple times during an ongoing lecture, some women were brave enough to sit in the back of the men’s section. I can’t say I take credit for initiating it. I remember my heart pounding as I entered that space. It did feel awkward and I hate so much that it needs to be that way. No one, including men and imam giving the lecture seemed to mind. Nor, did they acknowledge us.
February 1, 2011 at 10:46 pm
Seriously, it’s ridiculous to think that we could sit next to a man on the bus, but the second we enter into an Islamic space, we’re made to feel frightened or wronged. It’s also terrible how many forget to acknowledge women, one-on-one or even from the pulpit, only addressing the “brothers.” That’s another reason I stopped going to jummah.
On a positive note, once during a wedding, before beginning with the proceedings, an imam called up the women from the back and told us to sit with the men. He literally had to invite us repeatedly, and even after we moved, told us to sit closer. He was like, “Come on, it’s a wedding, come and be next to the families on this joyous occasion!”
Though, in a way it’s sad that we felt we required permission.
February 1, 2011 at 2:45 pm
Yes I have ventured out. One time it was Eid prayers in the hotel hall but they do have a wall put up to seperate the two, well me and another sister could not hear the lecture so we went to the mens side in the back of the men and sat down and listened. Another time was when I had my own key to our masjid in my city and late at night when noone was there I went to the masjid to reflect and would always go straight to the mans side and snoop around…lol
February 1, 2011 at 10:48 pm
Welcome!
And good for you! Did you ever find anything good on their side
Way to score a key to the masjid — how did you manage that?
February 2, 2011 at 1:15 am
It’s a small muslim community. OH I managed it because often I came to pray and the women’s door was always locked, so finally someone gave me a key. Oh I did, of course. they had books musliim magazines posters lol
February 2, 2011 at 9:49 am
When I first crossed the line, a man informed me that this was the “men’s area.” I shot him a withering look and proceeded to pray. No one said anything after that, but I could feel them staring. Even some of the women who passed gave me reproachful glances. But only a couple.
I was hoping the rest (or at least 1 or 2) would join me, but no one did.
Maybe someday!
April 15, 2012 at 6:17 pm
This comment has been removed by the moderator.